Shunning the most carbon-intensive sectors will not help the world achieve net zero emissions, according to a report by BNY Mellon Investment Management and Fathom Consulting. The report’s analysis finds the highest emitting sectors are, in fact, those most in need of investors’ capital to address climate change.
According to the report, around US$100 trillion needs to be invested in lower-carbon infrastructure for the world to reach goals set by the Paris Accord. This sum includes around US$20 trillion of ‘stranded’ assets that will need to be scrapped or retrofitted before the end of their useful life.
The report, An investor’s guide to net zero by 2050, estimates nearly half of all net zero specific corporate sector investment will need to come from companies in just two sectors – energy and utilities – even though together they account for just 6% of global market capitalization and face the highest transition risks.
But the report identifies an issue in that the sectors most in need of investment to achieve net zero goals are, at least in part, being shunned by some investors for the very same reasons.
It says simply selling these assets is not an effective strategy to address climate change because energy and utility companies remain essential to the global economy and need capital to survive and re-align with net zero. But the report also notes that companies in these sectors need to ramp up their spending on green assets significantly from current levels, if the Paris climate goal is to be met.
“Impact investors, ESG (environmental, social and governance) investors and sustainability investors need to consider these issues carefully – as do regulators, incumbents in these sectors and other stakeholders,” says the report. “Divesting from these sectors will not solve climate change or ensure that the Paris goal is met. The utilities and energy sectors need capital, but they need to use that capital for green investment – and do much more of it than they have been doing thus far.”
Analysis by the report’s authors, Shamik Dhar, chief economist at BNY Mellon Investment Management, and Brian Davidson, head of climate economics at Fathom Consulting, scores the transition risk of 24 stock market sectors in relation to companies’ exposure to carbon taxes, stranded assets and speed of transition. It finds energy and utilities, as well as airlines, carry the highest risk in relation to the net zero transition compared with other sectors. This means the bill carried by these sectors by not transitioning to net zero is likely to be higher than others.
Among these risks is the impact of carbon taxes under which companies are required to pay for each ton of greenhouse gas emissions they emit, according to a price set by the respective government. The report finds earnings of companies in all three sectors would be harder hit by any new carbon taxes compared with other sectors (see chart below).
Carbon tax effect and implied net zero date
Percent reduction in EBITDA due to $50/ton carbon tax**
Source: Refinitiv Eikon/BNYM/Fathom Consulting. As of September 2022.
Speed of transition
Utilities is rated high risk for its transition speed because the report finds it is expected to decarbonize faster than any other sector, owing to greater pressure from regulators and investors and the relatively low cost of low carbon alternatives in this sector. The authors explain: “Decarbonizing quickly creates risks and increases the chances of existing assets becoming stranded.” They add: “Being required to decarbonize quicker is likely to compound the risk of exposure to carbon taxes (and indeed, make the risk of carbon taxes materializing more likely). These risks are not just hypothetical: they are becoming real.”
For example, some countries are planning on decarbonizing their electricity generation sectors by 2035 and are introducing legislation on carbon reductioni. Indeed, in June 2021 the UK government set in law a climate change target of cutting emissions by 78% by 2035 compared to 1990 levelsii.
The stranded asset risk for these sectors is elevated also because they have a higher share of fixed assets that will likely need replacing to be consistent with net zero. “More asset-intensive industries, where those assets depreciate slowly and a high share of them need replacing to meet zero, will be most at risk,” the report says. “The airlines, utilities and energy industries fall into this category.”
Energy and utilities are particularly asset-intensive reflected by their lower ratio of market capitalization to property, plant and equipment (PPE) assets than the market average, according to Dhar and Davidson. Since 2014, the ratio of market capitalization to PPE for the S&P 500 overall has risen significantly, yet it has fallen in both the airlines and energy sectors. The ratio has increased slightly for the utilities sector (see chart below).
Market cap to PPE, selected S&P 500 sectors
Ratio (both axes)
Source: Refinitiv Eikon/BNYM/Fathom Consulting. As of September 2022.
The report points out all three sectors tend to be asset-intensive, meaning this ratio is typically lower in these sectors than the market average. Another interpretation is that this reflects a discount compared to other sectors for climate-related considerations.
Some investors may have avoided these sectors on the belief they are responsible for a high share of carbon emissions, the report states. Additionally, some investors could be concerned about these companies’ ability to make adequate green investments and/or the cost to their bottom line of doing so.
However, the report concludes: “For the transition to be achieved, investors must dedicate more funds to these sectors; and for maximum effectiveness they must do so to the companies that have credible decarbonization and green investment plans.”
i www.gov.uk. Plans unveiled to decarbonize UK power system by 2035. October 7, 2021
ii www.gov.uk. UK enshrines new target in law to slash emissions by 78% by 2035. April 20, 2021
Glossary – key terms
Climate Change: Warming of the planet caused by greenhouse gases is one of the most serious challenges facing humanity and efforts to halt global warming are at the heart of many Responsible Investment initiatives.
Decarbonization: Stopping or lowering the amount of carbon gases released in the atmosphere by burning fossil fuels.
Green Investment: Supports businesses and practices committed to the conservation of natural resources and reducing pollution.
Net Zero: The balance between the amount of greenhouse gases produced and the amount removed from the atmosphere.
Paris Climate Accord: The legally binding international treaty on climate change which came into force in November 2016 (not 2015 when it was agreed). It covers climate change mitigation, adaptation and finance. Its goal is to limit global warming to well below 2 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels and preferably limit the increase to 1.5 degrees Celsius.
Stranded Assets: Assets that are worth less than expected due to unanticipated or premature write-downs, devaluation or conversion to liabilities.
S&P 500 (The Standard and Poor's 500): Widely regarded as the best single gauge of large-cap US equities. The index includes 500 leading companies and captures approximately 80% coverage of available market capitalization.
All investments involve some level of risk, including loss of principal. Certain investments have specific or unique risks. No investment strategy or risk-management technique can guarantee results or eliminate risk in any market environment.
Recent market risks include pandemic risks related to COVID-19. The effects of COVID-19 have contributed to increased volatility in global markets and will likely affect certain countries, companies, industries and market sectors more dramatically than others.
This material has been provided for informational purposes only and should not be construed as tax advice, investment advice or a recommendation of any particular investment product, strategy, investment manager or account arrangement, and should not serve as a primary basis for investment decisions. Prospective investors should consult a legal, tax or financial professional in order to determine whether any investment product, strategy or service is appropriate for their particular circumstances. Views expressed are those of the author stated and do not reflect views of other managers or the firm overall. Views are current as of the date of this publication and subject to change.
This information contains projections or other forward-looking statements regarding future events, targets or expectations, and is only current as of the date indicated. There is no assurance that such events or expectations will be achieved, and actual results may be significantly different from that shown here. The information is based on current market conditions, which will fluctuate and may be superseded by subsequent market events or for other reasons. References to specific securities, asset classes and financial markets are for illustrative purposes only and are not intended to be and should not be interpreted as recommendations. Information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but not guaranteed.
There is no guarantee that any strategy that considers environmental, social, and governance (ESG) factors will be successful, or that any strategy will reflect the beliefs or values of any particular investor. Because ESG criteria exclude some investments, investors may not be able to take advantage of the same opportunities as investors that do not use such criteria.
No part of this material may be reproduced in any form, or referred to in any other publication, without express written permission.
BNY Mellon Investment Management is one of the world’s leading investment management organizations, encompassing BNY Mellon’s affiliated management firms and global distribution companies. BNY Mellon is the corporate brand of The Bank of New York Mellon Corporations and may also be used as a generic term to references the corporation as a whole or its various subsidiaries generally.
While Fathom's proprietary climate data and tools were used to develop the sectoral risk framework presented in the Report, Fathom Consulting is not affiliated with BNY Mellon.
© 2022 BNY Mellon Securities Corporation, distributor, 240 Greenwich Street, 9th Floor, New York NY, 10286
Not FDIC-Insured | No Bank Guarantee | May Lose Value