Please ensure Javascript is enabled for purposes of website accessibility

Why this isn't 2008

  • Tweet
  • Share on LinkedIn
  • Share via email
  • Print
  • Download

April 2023

Does history repeat? We believe today’s upset in financials isn’t new territory – but neither does it seem like it’s a rerun of 2008. Here’s why.

Bailouts, bank failures and government interventions – it’s easy to see why March 2023 is reminiscent of Autumn 2008. But just because the words are the same, evoking such a difficult time doesn’t mean history is repeating itself. Although it may just be that 2008 is responsible for what is happening today.

Over 15 years after the Global Financial Crisis (GFC), sparked by the collapse of a bank, the world is once more in a rising interest-rate environment and fighting inflation. Investment experts across BNY Mellon Investment Management point out that with interest rates rising alongside costs, it’s little wonder some companies are struggling to service their debts.

Source: Macrobond, BNY Mellon Investment Management. Data as of March 24, 2023. The Chicago Board Options Exchange Volatility Index (CBOE VIX) is calculated in real time and measures the expected volatility of the S&P 500 Index options over the next 30 days. Past performance is not a guide to future performance.

But while the market volatility and bearish sentiment created by the March 12 collapse of the US regional Silicon Valley Bank (SVB) and the March 19 “emergency” takeover of Credit Suisse are concerning, investment professionals argue this isn’t 2008.

Shamik Dhar, chief economist at BNY Mellon Investment Management, notes in both cases (SVB and Credit Suisse) it was concerns about the profitability of the banks that triggered a “run” by depositors.

Roy Leckie, executive director at Walter Scott, notes the backdrop for banks was already looking fragile ahead of SVB:

“We have been through an extraordinary period of monetary stimuli since the GFC, and corporate debt has been rising. There are plenty of sub-par businesses, bloated with debt, whose returns and financial health have been propped up by cheap financing. More expensive money may pose a threat to these businesses, leading to a deterioration of the nonperforming loan picture and therefore a dilution of the beneficial impact of rising interest rates and economic growth.”

Newton’s Real Return team says: “SVB operated in a niche area of lending and Credit Suisse’s financial performance had been sub-par for some years. Still the ripple effects of recent events are causing widespread unease and stress in markets. It has also led to fears that other signs of fragility may emerge. “Rising interest rates have highlighted financial strains, and management teams caught on the wrong side of a less benign monetary environment have struggled to navigate this challenging situation. But financial leaders have moved swiftly to try and contain any fallout and pre-empt any further contagion. It remains to be seen whether this will be sufficient.”

Euan Munro, chief executive officer of Newton Investment Management stops short of comparing today’s market backdrop to 2008:

“Questions around whether we are entering a new 2008-style banking crisis are not without a total lack of merit, although in our view, this is not the case. Bank capital rules imposed after 2008 have ensured the capital positions of most within the sector remain strong and credit quality remains robust. Such reassurances may have been lost in the face of the market panic afflicting bank shares.”

“The bullish assessment that there is little fundamental reasoning to distrust the viability of European and UK banks is certainly being outdone by bearish sentiment. Credit losses are low and capital levels strong, so the likelihood that the collapse of Credit Suisse and regional US banks is indicative of what’s to come appears overblown. Yet, central banks do now have less maneuverability than they did in 2008 should the rising-rate environment start to eat into capital buffers.”

Martin Chambers, credit analyst at Newton Investment Management, points out banks are very cyclical beasts. As such, if anyone is suffering from the higher borrowing-cost environment, it is sure to be felt by the banks. While Chambers says he would not rule out a financial crisis completely, he does not believe this is a rerun of 2008 “in any way.”

He says: “In terms of financials, we do not believe this is a systemic issue. We see Credit Suisse as an isolated, idiosyncratic issue within the European banking space. It was unprofitable and poorly managed for a number of years, with clear control deficiencies. While we did not expect it to go under, it was long seen as the weakest link among the major European banks. In terms of the broader market, while we appreciate that as central banks raise rates there are likely to be higher arrears and defaults within loan books, banks are generally well capitalised and well managed, so we see this as more of a hit to profitability rather than a balance-sheet issue.”

But that’s not to say the impact of the rising-rate environment won’t continue to be felt by markets. “There could be a number of companies out there who have been bolstered by very cheap borrowing costs for a number of years who may now find conditions more challenging.”

As such, Chambers expects a European recession this year. Dhar agrees and believes the tightening credit conditions may also be sufficient to send the US into a (mild) recession later this year.

Amid many volatile and uncertain market environments, the appeal of sovereign debt rises. We believe that this time is no different. Chambers notes that while there may be pockets of difficulties in some high-risk credit resulting from the March volatility, there is sufficient liquidity within the sovereign-bond space.

Dhar says in this environment he expects risk assets to be under pressure. However, he remains relatively positive on fixed income assets. He says: “The fixed income opportunity set is arguably more attractive than any seen in decades. And while compensation for taking duration risk remains low (many yield curves are inverted), we argue that attempting to precisely time the next big yield curve move should be avoided. Markets can move quickly and unexpectedly, as highlighted by the March banking sector drama.”

“Staying defensive and nimble translates more specifically into a preference for cash-like and sovereign bonds that currently offer attractive yields. Our latest forecasts make us somewhat more cautious on credit exposure due to the possibility that spreads widen considerably during a recession. Remaining up in quality and pairing with active bond selection will be needed to successfully manage credit risk. We continue to prefer investment grade to high yield.”

Dhar adds that amid the current uncertainty, he believes a sensible multi-asset approach is to be balanced, well diversified, and defensive in portfolio allocation while maintaining the ability to be nimble as the economy evolves. “Portfolio resiliency, the ability to withstand and thrive under different market environments, will be key.”

Source: Macrobond, BNY Mellon Investment Management.
Eurex Exchange, ECB (European Central Bank), Intercontinental Exchange (ICE), Bank of England, CME Group, Federal Reserve Bank of New York.
Data as of March 24, 2023. Past performance is not a guide to future performance.


All investments involve risk, including the possible loss of principal. Certain investments involve greater or unique risks that should be considered along with the objectives, fees, and expenses before investing.

“Newton” and/or the “Newton Investment Management” brand refers to the following group of affiliated companies: Newton Investment Management Limited (NIM) and Newton Investment Management North America LLC (NIMNA). NIM is incorporated in the United Kingdom (Registered in England no. 1371973) and is authorized and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority in the conduct of investment business. Both Newton firms are registered with the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in the United States of America as an investment adviser under the Investment Advisers Act of 1940. Newton is a subsidiary of The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation. Newton’s investment advisory businesses are described in their Form ADVs, Part 1 and 2, which can be obtained from the website or obtained upon request.

Walter Scott & Partners Limited (“Walter Scott”) is an investment management firm authorized and regulated in the United Kingdom by the Financial Conduct Authority in the conduct of investment business. Walter Scott is a subsidiary of The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation.

BNY Mellon Investment Management is one of the world’s leading investment management organizations, encompassing BNY Mellon’s affiliated investment management firms and global distribution companies. BNY Mellon is the corporate brand of The Bank of New York Mellon Corporation and may also be used as a generic term to reference the corporation as a whole or its various subsidiaries generally.

This material has been provided for informational purposes only and should not be construed as investment advice or a recommendation of any particular investment product, strategy, investment manager or account arrangement, and should not serve as a primary basis for investment decisions.

Prospective investors should consult a legal, tax or financial professional in order to determine whether any investment product, strategy or service is appropriate for their particular circumstances. Views expressed are those of the author stated and do not reflect views of other managers or the firm overall. Views are current as of the date of this publication and subject to change.

The information is based on current market conditions, which will fluctuate and may be superseded by subsequent market events or for other reasons. References to specific securities, asset classes and financial markets are for illustrative purposes only and are not intended to be and should not be interpreted as recommendations. Information contained herein has been obtained from sources believed to be reliable, but not guaranteed. No part of this material may be reproduced in any form, or referred to in any other publication, without express written permission.

Not FDIC-Insured | No Bank Guarantee | May Lose Value

© 2023 BNY Mellon Securities Corporation, distributor, 240 Greenwich Street, 9th Floor, New York, NY 10286

MARK-365967-2023-03-30. T11394 04/23